Either case you will only have the one time you gain dark side points.

You can actually do a mix and match of options 2 and 3, by telling the droid your evil plan, and then telling Elise that the droid is destroyed, or the other way by telling the droid you will destroy it for her sake, and afterwards deceive Elise that the droid is still alive. Tricking her will net you another 150 XP. You get dark side points both when you tell the droid your plan and when you trick Elise. Destroy the robot and tell him that you'll trick Elise to come out into the wilderness herself for 300 XP.Talk to her and she apologizes for her earlier actions and thanks you for another 150 XP. Find her in the guest rooms of the Jedi Enclave with her new boyfriend. Go back and tell her the droid has been destroyed to see her run off in distress for 150 XP (you get XP for making lonely old women cry?). Destroy the robot to help Elise out for 200 XP.Talk to Elise for some XP after which they go off for another 200 XP. Tell the robot to return to Elise for 300 XP.There are three ways you can deal with this situation. It will say that it ran away because Elise was far too obsessed with it. Save the droid from the Kath Hounds and talk to it. The Droid is located near the mouth of the Crystal Caves in the Sandral Grounds. She tells you her companion is missing, and by mistake reveals that her companion is her droid. If you demand more money you can gain some dark side points, while refusing any reward will give you light side points, and you still get to keep the 1000 credits he gives you.

Loot the corpses once they are down for some great loot and return to Jon for your reward of 1000 Credits and 250 XP. Defeating Sherruk will net you a 200 XP Bonus. If you have Force whirlwind, use that on Sherruk as that can keep him incapacitated. If you are having problems grenades and energy shields can help. Nearing their camp triggers a conversation, so scoundrels will be out of luck here. There you will meet Sherruk, the leader of the Mandalorians who has even killed several Jedi. Once all three groups are eliminated go back to where you found the second group, in the south central portion of the Grove. The first group you eliminate will give you a 50 XP bonus. Make sure you loot all of the dead Mandalorian corpses as they generally have good equipment. The Duros are weak so you might want to eliminate them quickly before hitting the Mandalorians. Use grenades and energy shields if you having trouble. All of these groups should be rather easy to defeat. The first one is located in the east portion of the Matale Grounds, the second south of the center of the Grove, and the third in the central portion of the Sandral Grounds. To complete this quest you must first defeat three Mandalorian raider camps. Get some dark side points by either asking for a reward or by saying you're going to slaughter the Mandalorians. His daughter was killed by Mandalorian Raiders and asks for you help in avenging her death. You cannot avoid receiving this quest as Jon will talk to you when you try to pass him.

Kotor skipping dialogue bug